The Golden Bachelor stars Gerry Turner and Theresa Nist were together for less than six months, and in the year since they announced their live TV wedding, Bachelor Nation hasn’t gotten over their relationship. Although viewers were excited for the idea of The Golden Bachelor, the way it panned out wasn’t exactly the most palatable for Bachelor Nation. Throughout the season, viewers got to know Gerry, a widower from Indiana who was looking for love after losing his wife unexpectedly. Though Gerry was presented as a wholesome father and grandfather, it turned out that he was more flawed than expected.