American Idol season 23’s newest judge, Carrie Underwood, has been struggling to find her footing on the show and despite making some progress, some of these potential replacements could be a better fit for American Idol season 24. While Carrie has been an interesting addition to American Idol season 23 thus far, it’s becoming clear that she’s not likely to be a long-term solution to the problem on the series. With a lot of moving parts on Idol, Carrie has exacerbated some problems and brought others out of the woodwork. While she’s not the issue, she isn’t the solution, either.